The Refreshing Story of the Mint Julep and Its Kentucky Derby Legacy

Few drinks capture the spirit of Southern hospitality and tradition quite like the mint julep. This cool, minty cocktail has become synonymous with the Kentucky Derby, where it is served by the thousands each spring. But how did this simple mix of bourbon, mint, sugar, and ice rise to such iconic status? The story of the mint julep is as rich and layered as the drink itself, blending history, culture, and a touch of Southern charm.

The Origins of the Mint Julep

The mint julep is far older, more contested, and more scientifically interesting than the pretty cup of crushed ice and bourbon most people encounter once a year on the first Saturday in May. The drink traces back over a thousand years to Persian rosewater remedies, traveled through Arabic medicine and medieval apothecaries, and landed in Virginia tobacco country as a morning pick-me-up made with rum — not bourbon — before Kentucky ever claimed it. Today, Churchill Downs moves more than 120,000 juleps over Derby weekend. The julep's story is one of reinvention: from medicine to cocktail, from Virginia to Kentucky, from brandy to bourbon, from silver heirloom to $22 souvenir glass. Here's everything worth knowing.

A rose by any other name: how a Persian remedy became a Kentucky icon

The word "julep" comes from the Persian gulāb — literally "rose water." The term passed through Arabic as julāb, then into Medieval Latin as julapium, Old French, and finally Middle English around the 1380s, where it described a sweet syrup used to deliver medicine. For centuries, juleps were pharmacy, not bar. Dr. Samuel Johnson's 1755 dictionary defined a "julap" as "an extemporaneous form of medicine made of simple and compound water sweetened." John Milton described a "cordial julep" in Comus (1634) as "spirits of balm and fragrant syrups mixed."

The leap from apothecary shelf to cocktail glass happened in the American South. In the Mediterranean, locally abundant mint had already replaced rose petals in the drink (Latin apothecaries called it julapum menthae), and Virginia colonists adopted the mint-and-spirit version as a morning ritual called an "antifogmatic" — a dram taken at dawn to ward off the ill effects of swamp fog, which they believed caused malaria. The earliest American references are all Virginian: Robert Munford's satirical play The Candidate (1770) features a drunkard named "Mr. Julip," and a poem in the Williamsburg Virginia Gazette that same year describes the julep as a concoction "which doctors storm at, and which some adore."

By 1787, a traveler described in American Museum magazine how "the Virginian rises in the morning, about six o'clock. He then drinks a julap, made of rum, water and sugar, but very strong." Note: no mint, and rum, not bourbon. The first recorded mention of mint specifically in a recreational julep comes from Reverend Harry Toulmin in 1793, who described it in Norfolk, Virginia as "a tumbler of rum and water, well sweetened, with a slip of mint in it." The reference most cocktail historians cite as the canonical first published mention belongs to Englishman John Davis, who wrote in his 1803 Travels of Four Years and a Half in the United States of America that a julep was "a dram of spirituous liquor that has mint steeped in it, taken by Virginians of a morning."

Virginia is the julep's best-documented early American home. Every early reference points there. Kentucky's claim came later, through migration and economics. When Virginians settled west of the Appalachians (Kentucky was part of Virginia until 1792), they brought their drinking habits. As bourbon whiskey production exploded in Kentucky in the early 1800s, it replaced imported rum and expensive brandy as the julep's base spirit — a substitution driven by cost, availability, and the loose enforcement of whiskey excise taxes on the frontier. The phylloxera epidemic of the 1870s–1880s, which devastated French vineyards and made cognac scarce, permanently cemented bourbon's place. By 1900, "mint julep" meant bourbon.

How the Mint Julep Became the Kentucky Derby’s Official Drink

Henry Clay, Jasper Crouch, and the people who made the julep famous

Henry Clay, the Kentucky senator and perennial presidential candidate, is the figure most closely linked to the julep's spread beyond the South. In the 1830s, Clay began mixing juleps for fellow legislators at what is now the Round Robin Bar in Washington D.C.'s Willard InterContinental Hotel. He shipped barrels of Kentucky sour mash corn whiskey to the capital specifically for this purpose  — at a time when most julep drinkers in polite society still preferred brandy. The Round Robin still serves its signature "Henry Clay Mint Julep" today, preserving the ritual he helped popularize — gently pressing fresh mint in a silver cup rather than aggressively muddling it — a technique that remains central to a proper julep.

But the julep's true masters were often Black Americans whose contributions went under-credited for generations. Jasper Crouch, a free man of color in Richmond, Virginia, is acknowledged as the first master of the mint julep. He served as caterer and mixologist for the Richmond Quoit Club, whose members included Chief Justice John Marshall of the U.S. Supreme Court. An 1891 New York Times account recalls Marshall arriving at the club in 1828 and, when offered a handshake, reaching past it toward a tumbler of julep: "I'd rather shake hands with that."

John Dabney, born enslaved in Hanover County, Virginia, created the legendary "Julep à la Dabney" — a spectacle served in a massive tin bucket with bourbon, mint, sugar, nearly a gallon of ice, and topped with layers of fruit. His patrons included Edward VII, Prince of Wales. Dabney earned enough from his bartending to purchase freedom for himself and his wife. Other notable julep lovers include Theodore Roosevelt, Edgar Allan Poe, and F. Scott Fitzgerald, who featured the drink in The Great Gatsby. Ernest Hemingway allegedly smashed a glass in a French bar because a julep was made incorrectly.

The silver cup: why metal matters and how it became heirloom

The silver or pewter julep cup isn't affectation — it's physics. Metal's high thermal conductivity transfers cold from the crushed ice inside to the cup's exterior surface almost instantly. Ambient humidity condenses and freezes on the outside, forming the drink's signature frost. A glass tumbler insulates; it will never frost. You lose half the experience.

The Kentucky julep cup tradition centers on one silversmith: Asa Blanchard (c. 1770–1838), who moved from Virginia to Lexington, Kentucky in 1806 and became early Kentucky's most prolific silversmith. His cups, produced from roughly 1808 to 1838, are now the most coveted by collectors and considered among the finest examples of American silver.

PBS's Antiques Roadshow has called Blanchard "the best silversmith as far as mint julep cups go, and what every collector of Southern mint julep cups wants." By 1816, the Kentucky Gazette recorded that julep cups were being awarded as prizes at Kentucky horse races — a tradition connecting the drink to horse culture decades before the Derby existed. The julep cup became a standard Southern gift for christenings, weddings, and graduations, monogrammed and passed down through generations. Mark J. Scearce of Shelbyville, Kentucky later established the tradition of Presidential julep cups, with each bearing an eagle cartouche and the initials of the sitting president. A cup was even engraved for Prince George of England upon his christening.

Proper julep cup etiquette: hold it only by the top rim or the base, never wrapping your hand around the body. Your hand's warmth will melt the frost and warm the drink. The untouched frost is proof the drink is properly cold.

120,000 juleps and a bourbon that wasn't bourbon: the Derby connection

Colonel Meriwether Lewis Clark Jr. — grandson of William Clark of Lewis and Clark fame — founded Churchill Downs and the Kentucky Derby in 1875. He reportedly planted mint behind the clubhouse, and Chris Goodlett, director of curatorial affairs at the Kentucky Derby Museum, confirms: "We have every reason to assume that juleps were a part of the first Derby in 1875, as they were popular drinks in the state at that time."

The mint julep became the official drink of the Kentucky Derby in 1938, though the catalyst was amusingly practical. Staff noticed after that year's race that patrons were stealing decorated water glasses as souvenirs. Rather than fight the trend, Churchill Downs leaned in and began selling juleps in commemorative souvenir glasses, initially for 75 cents. The move reportedly tripled drink sales. Today, approximately 750,000 souvenir glasses are produced annually, with more than two-thirds sold off-track for private Derby parties. In 2025, the standard julep in a souvenir glass costs $22.

The ingredient numbers at scale are staggering: Churchill Downs uses roughly 10,000 bottles of bourbon, 2,250 pounds of freshly harvested mint, and 475,000 pounds of crushed ice (that's nearly 238 tons) over the two-day Oaks-Derby weekend to produce more than 120,000 mint juleps.

The bourbon behind those juleps has its own controversy. For roughly 20 years (c. 1987–2014), the "Official Mint Julep of the Kentucky Derby" was made with Early Times — which was technically not bourbon under U.S. law because it was aged in used barrels rather than the required new charred oak. It was sold as "Kentucky whiskey" domestically, though marketed as bourbon overseas. Bourbon purists were vocal about this. In 2015, Old Forester replaced Early Times as the official julep bourbon — an actual bourbon, restoring credibility.  Meanwhile, Woodford Reserve has been the "Official Bourbon of the Kentucky Derby" since 1999 and was elevated to presenting sponsor in 2018 (renewed through at least 2027). The distinction matters: Woodford is the marquee name and makes the luxury cups, but Old Forester is what's actually in the standard $22 julep you buy trackside. Both brands are Brown-Forman products.

There’s also a detail here that julep purists love to fuss over: when you’re pouring more than 120,000 mint juleps over Oaks and Derby weekend, practicality inevitably enters the chat. The standard version is designed for speed and consistency, while the premium cups get the more handmade, white-glove treatment. And naturally, I’d be ordering the handmade one. Standards, darling.

The $1,000 cup and other premium Derby julep traditions

Since 2006, Churchill Downs has offered ultra-premium juleps in collectible cups, with proceeds benefiting charity. The program now runs at two tiers: a $1,000 cup (polished pewter with sterling silver accents and a sterling silver sipping straw) and a $5,000 cup (24-karat gold plating over sterling silver). In 2025, the cups were embellished with lab-grown white and pink sapphires and handcrafted by Louisville jeweler From the Vault. Only 151 total cups were produced for the 151st Derby — 51 pewter and 100 gold-plated. They sell out fast and have become collectible in their own right.

The premium julep recipe changes annually with a creative theme. The 2025 "Filly Mint Julep" used Woodford Reserve bourbon with hand-crafted simple syrup and three mint varieties — chocolate mint, peppermint, and spearmint — honoring three Derby-winning fillies: Regret (1915), Genuine Risk (1980), and Winning Colors (1988). Previous years have featured rose-infused honey syrup, mint imported from Ireland, and spring water ice from the Bavarian Alps. Charity beneficiaries have included retired racehorse sanctuaries, the Backside Learning Center supporting racetrack workers, and the Wounded Warrior Equestrian Program.

A few more pieces of Derby julep trivia worth knowing: the 1940 souvenir glass is the holy grail for collectors, with one reportedly selling for $30,000. During World War II (1942–1944), aluminum was rationed, so Churchill Downs used Beetleware (Bakelite ceramic) tumblers that are now worth $2,000–$3,000. In 2008, Churchill Downs unveiled the world's largest mint julep glass — six feet tall (seven and a half feet including the mint sprig), holding 206 gallons, equivalent to about 5,000 juleps.

Building the perfect julep: recipe, ratios, and the science of cold

After surveying recipes from Woodford Reserve, legendary New Orleans bartender Chris McMillian, Serious Eats, Difford's Guide, and several Louisville bourbon bars, the consensus recipe is remarkably consistent:

• 2–2.5 oz bourbon (90+ proof recommended)

• ½ oz simple syrup (1:1 ratio)

• 8–10 fresh spearmint leaves

• Crushed ice, packed generously

• Large mint sprig bouquet for garnish

  
  

The build, step by step: Start with a pre-chilled metal julep cup (15 minutes in the freezer). Place mint leaves and simple syrup in the cup. Using a flat-bottomed muddler or the back of a spoon, press gently and twist 3–5 times — just enough to bruise the leaves and release aromatic oils. Some bartenders rub a mint leaf around the interior of the cup first. Add bourbon. Fill halfway with crushed ice and stir briskly for 10–30 seconds. Pack more crushed ice in a generous dome extending above the rim, like a snow cone. Wait 30–45 seconds for frost to develop on the outside of the cup. Slap a large bouquet of fresh mint firmly between your palms (you'll hear a "pop" and smell the burst), then plant it in the ice right next to a short-cut straw — the straw should protrude only about an inch above the ice. (and i like to add a slice of jalapeno or muddle one in the bottom for the bourbon brunette touch!)

The mint debate is the julep's most heated argument. Over-muddling is the single most common mistake. Aggressive crushing ruptures leaf veins and releases chlorophyll, which tastes bitter  and grassy. Chris McMillian puts it bluntly: "Many bartenders think they're demonstrating their skill by showing off their muddling technique, but you're really just supposed to delicately release the oil of the mint." The volatile essential oils — menthol, limonene, and other terpenes — sit mostly on the leaf's surface. A gentle press or even a firm slap between the palms is enough to release them without extracting bitterness. Woodford Reserve's own official recipe calls for "expressing" the mint, not muddling it. Historically, the earliest juleps had mint "steeped" in spirits, and an 1895 recipe book specifies that a julep's mint was stirred into the drink while a "smash" had its mint muddled. The traditional method is gentleness.

Crushed ice is non-negotiable, and the reason is thermodynamics. Crushed ice has dramatically more surface area per gram than cubes, meaning faster heat transfer, faster chilling, and faster dilution. As cocktail scientist Dave Arnold articulated in his "Fundamental Law of Traditional Cocktails": there is no chilling without dilution, and no dilution without chilling. Melting a gram of ice absorbs 333.5 joules of energy — two orders of magnitude more cooling power than simply warming cold liquid. A julep is an unusually strong drink (essentially 2+ ounces of bourbon with only half an ounce of sweetener), and it needs that dilution to become refreshing rather than punishing. At sub-freezing temperatures, sweetness perception drops, so the sugar doesn't taste cloying. As bartender Tom Macy explains: "The Mint Julep is an unbalanced cocktail by today's standards... when chilled down to below freezing levels, it doesn't come off as cloying, but rather, unbearably delicious."  To crush ice at home, the gold standard is a Lewis bag and wooden mallet — the thick canvas absorbs excess moisture, leaving dry, shattered ice shards rather than slushy melt.

Simple syrup versus granulated sugar is a less heated debate. Granulated sugar has historical precedent and the granules act as a mild abrasive that helps express mint oils during muddling. But cold liquid makes sugar hard to dissolve, risking grittiness. Simple syrup (1:1 water to sugar) is pre-dissolved, consistent, and what nearly every modern professional recipe specifies. Demerara simple syrup is a worthwhile upgrade — its caramel and molasses notes complement bourbon beautifully.

The mint garnish is not decoration. It's functional aromatherapy. Up to 80% of what humans perceive as taste is actually smell, delivered through retronasal olfaction. By positioning a fragrant mint bouquet exactly where your nose lands when sipping, every sip delivers a burst of volatile menthol and aromatic terpenes. You smell the mint but taste the bourbon — the two sensations merge into the full julep experience. As one bartender instructs: "Cut your straw short so that your nose is forced into the mint bouquet every time you take a sip."

Choosing the right bourbon: why proof and mashbill matter

Not every bourbon makes a good julep, and the best julep bourbon isn't necessarily the best sipping bourbon. Because crushed ice dilutes aggressively, you need a bourbon with enough proof and flavor to hold up. 90–100 proof is the sweet spot. Lower proofs wash out; barrel-proof monsters are overkill. And because mint, sugar, and ice will dominate the nuance, spending $60+ on a single-barrel expression is wasted money.

Woodford Reserve ($35, 90.4 proof) earns its Derby association honestly. Its flavor profile — vanilla, honey, light citrus, toffee, and notably a natural mint note on the palate — complements a julep's ingredients without fighting them. Breaking Bourbon calls it "a good base for cocktails" precisely because its "straightforward and approachable flavor profile doesn't overpower the drink." It's not the most complex sipper at its price point, but cocktail utility isn't about complexity — it's about integration.

Old Forester 86 ($19–25, 86 proof) is the bartender's value pick, and for good reason. Its official tasting notes include "fresh spearmint" and "clove spice" — the bourbon literally already tastes like julep ingredients. Founded in 1870 by George Garvin Brown, Old Forester is the only bourbon continuously distilled and marketed by the founding family before, during, and after Prohibition.  It was the first bourbon sold exclusively in sealed bottles. At roughly half the price of Woodford, it delivers above-average cocktail performance. Its Louisville heritage and status as the actual bourbon in the official Derby julep give it unimpeachable credentials. For a slightly bolder option, Old Forester 100 Proof (~$25) steps up nicely.

The wheated versus high-rye mashbill question comes down to personal preference. Wheated bourbons like Maker's Mark ($28–32, 90 proof) produce a softer, sweeter julep — vanilla and caramel integrating gently with mint and sugar. Bartender Kristina Magro calls Maker's "the perfect bourbon to make juleps because of its wheated mash bill, which gives it a natural depth that complements the mint and sugar perfectly." High-rye bourbons like Four Roses Small Batch ($30–35, 90 proof) or Wild Turkey 101 ($22–28, 101 proof) contribute spice that cuts through sweetness and provides structure. Four Roses Master Distiller Brent Elliott notes his bourbon "doesn't fold under the influence of other ingredients — it can stand up and give the cocktail structure." Buffalo Trace ($25–30, 90 proof) and Elijah Craig Small Batch ($28–33, 94 proof) are reliable middle-ground options.

Variations, smashes, and the wrong ways to make a julep

The Whiskey Smash is the julep's more casual, citrus-brightened cousin. Jerry Thomas called it "the Julep on a small plan" in 1887, though his original version was simply a smaller julep with no citrus. The modern Whiskey Smash — with muddled lemon — was popularized by Dale DeGroff in his 2003 The Craft of the Cocktail. DeGroff combined Thomas's smash with the Whiskey Cobbler's citrus elements because he was "bored with juleps made with just sugar, booze and mint." The result is shaken rather than built, served in a rocks glass, and significantly more approachable — citrus-forward where the julep is spirit-forward.

Modern variations worth noting include the Maple Mint Julep (maple syrup replacing simple syrup for warmth), Strawberry-Rhubarb Julep (rhubarb syrup adding tartness), and the simple but effective addition of a dash or two of Angostura bitters. Cocktail writer Peter Suderman is emphatic on this point: "Without the bitters, you end up with what amounts to bourbon plus made-in-glass mint syrup, which invariably ends up somewhat cloying." The bitters add the complexity and bittering element the julep otherwise lacks.

As for the wrong ways: pre-made mint julep mix is the cardinal sin. As one writer put it, a bad julep "can taste like someone raided the liquor cabinet and muddled the spoils with toothpaste and table sugar — especially true if the cocktail is made with the cloying julep mix found at the supermarket." Beyond that, the most common mistakes are over-muddling mint into bitter green soup, using cubed ice instead of crushed, serving in a glass instead of metal, and using sad, wilted mint. Louisville bartender Eron Plevan captures the frustration: "Most bartenders give a good eye-roll to the mint julep because for all the trouble, it's just an old fashioned — but with three times the work."

Is the mint julep actually good, or just famous?

This is the question that divides bourbon country every spring. Louisville bartender Nicole Stipp argues against: "Our palates crave some bitterness and acid no matter what, so it's a real sugar bomb with no balance to it." Plevan calls the finished product "a bad, sad-looking old fashioned." The volume problem compounds the reputation issue — most people's first julep is the pre-mixed, assembly-line version at the Derby or a poorly made bar version, not a carefully constructed drink.

But the defense is passionate. Louisville bartender Ian Montgomery counters: "If you have it the right way, to your desired sweetness, plus fresh mint in a cold julep tin with that little cap of crushed ice... it's impossible not to enjoy. It's actually one of my favorite cocktails." Chris McMillian, who recites 1880s prose while building juleps ("Then comes the zenith of man's pleasure, then comes the julep"), considers the drink one of the most multidimensional cocktails ever created. Tom Macy places it "in a category all its own" — possessing the booziness of a stirred cocktail but the refreshing quality of a shaken one.

The truth is that the julep is more technique-dependent than almost any other cocktail. A PUNCH magazine expert panel concluded that "more than other drinks, the julep is more technique-oriented than recipe-oriented... The julep might have more of the stamp of its maker than other drinks. You can't batch a mint julep." Made carelessly, it's a sweet, watery mess. Made with intention — gentle mint, proper ice, good bourbon, the right cup, frost forming on the outside — it's one of the most complete sensory experiences in cocktails: cold metal in your fingers, mint perfume in your nose, bourbon warmth in your chest.

General Simon Bolivar Buckner perhaps said it best: "A Mint Julep is not the product of a formula. It is a ceremony and must be performed by a gentleman possessing a true sense of the artistic, a deep reverence for the ingredients, and a proper appreciation of the occasion." The julep endures not despite its simplicity but because of it. Four ingredients. A thousand years of history. One perfect, frosty moment on a warm afternoon.

Final Thoughts: Sipping on Tradition

The mint julep's journey from Persian rosewater to Kentucky silver cup is a story of constant reinvention, and that's precisely what makes it endure. The drink belongs to Virginia by birth, to Kentucky by adoption, and to the Derby by brilliant marketing — yet it has always been shaped most by the people who make it, from Jasper Crouch's quiet mastery in 1820s Richmond to the bartender cutting a straw short at your local bourbon bar today. The key insight for anyone writing about the julep is that the debate over whether it's a "good" cocktail misses the point entirely. A well-made julep — gentle mint, proper crushed ice, frosted metal, bourbon at the right proof — isn't a simple drink performing above its station. It's an experience engineered across every sense: touch (cold cup), sight (frost and green), smell (mint bouquet), taste (bourbon and sweet), even sound (the crunch of ice). The cocktails that last centuries aren't the most complicated. They're the ones that, made right, make you stop and pay attention.

Want to save your Mint Julep History? Pin the post below